A Scientologist on psychiatry and the pharmaceutical industry
This is a great article giving one Scientologists view of psychiatry et al. I tend to agree.
Q:Hello, my name is Merisa Okic, a student of Medical Anthropology at the University of Kansas. I’m writing to you to ask you some questions on the topic of depression, and how this condition, disease, disorder, or whatever you’d like to classify it as, is viewed by the scientology community. While this email is born both out of curiosity and fascination with the scientologist’s view of depression, it is also born out of the requirements of an assignment. Yes, I’m emailing you to gather information for a paper. Am I looking for a definition I can find off the internet in 2.5 seconds? No, I’m interested in your professional opinion (as well as your personal opinion) on clinical depression, what it is, what it means, and how it can (and if it can) be cured. Your answers will be cited in a research paper comparing your answers with that of someone with a spiritual biomedical viewpoint on this topic, not in an effort to prove whose answers are “better” but merely to examine differences. If you choose to respond, your answers will be greatly appreciated.
8. What is depression?
9. What are the symptoms of depression?
10. What causes depression?
11. Is there a “cure” or way to treat the symptoms of depression?
12. Is depression on the rise/fall? Is it over-diagnosed/under-diagnosed?
13. In your opinion, is depression more a biological, psychological, or social condition/disorder?
14. What do you want people to know about depression? Any last words?
If you have anything to add, please feel free. Again, thank you for responding, if you choose to do so.
Sincerely,
Merisa Okic
mxokic@ku.edu
I’m glad to answer your question as best I can. I’m not sure that I can speak for the Scientology community at large, but I can give you my understanding of what Scientology teaches about this subject.
I believe that depression is well defined in any standard English dictionary. I don’t think there’s really any dispute about how to define depression. As I understand it, it is a reduction of spirits, gloominess, listlessness, hopelessness, apathy. It’s a condition wherein the person essentially loses interest in life and is sad and hopeless.
As for whether depression is increasing in incidence, it seems so, at least in the eyes of the psychiatrists. But there seems to be significant evidence that the psychiatric drugs that supposedly treat depression are in fact causing it (these are just a few references—there are plenty more). I don’t know whether it is over-diagnosed, but given the propensity of psychiatrists to diagnose anything as a mental disorder, it probably is.
Depression has a number of potential causes, ranging from nutritional to spiritual. For instance, someone can have a physical illness that makes him feel depressed, or someone can be so undernourished or lacking in vital nutrients that he feels depressed. Physical causes are best evaluated by a medical doctor or nutritionist. If there is no physical cause, however, or perhaps in addition to a physical cause, depression is caused by mental recordings of past moments of trauma, such as past pain or severe emotional stress. These past moments reactivate and affect the person when a similar situation is present in the present-time environment. However, these past recordings are active on the person below the level of consciousness, so he usually has little idea where the feelings he is experiencing are coming from. This is best expressed in the book Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health, and you can find more information here. In all cases, physical or spiritual, the effect is essentially one of suppression of the person’s purposes and drive toward his goals, which reduces his ability to survive—hence the feeling of depression. This can also be caused by someone or some situation in the environment creating an oppressive effect on the person. In this case the person will become depressed when he feels he cannot do anything about the situation.
There is a way to eradicate depression. The first step would be to eliminate any physical factors as causes, by having a competent medical doctor examine the person and handle any nutritional problems, illnesses or injuries. Then any environmental influences with an oppressive effect on the person should be addressed, and the person should be helped to gain some degree of control over them. If it is not possible to bring the person to such a degree of control, the influence can simply be disconnected from. Finally, any spiritual factors, as described above, would be addressed by using the techniques of Dianetics and Scientology to desensitize or eliminate those factors in the mind causing the depression.
I believe that answers your questions. If you have others, please feel free to ask.
About the practice of "silent birth" in Dianetics and Scientology
This is an excellent article dispelling the mystery and controversy around the practice of silent birth in Scientology. From the article:
The whole topic of “silent birth” took center stage a few years back when Katie Holmes was giving birth to her daughter, Suri, and due to the media frenzy that generally surrounds Tom Cruise or Katie, the media of course was then all too eager to report all manner of variations on what “silent birth” was, doing virtually everything except referring to actual Scientology writings by L. Ron Hubbard on the subject. Unfortunate, the tabloid pundits were all too willing to point out the “impracticality” of a “silent” birth, leaving beleaguered readers with odd impressions of be-gagged mothers trying to give birth in a cone of silence, or attending physicians jumping up and down with cue cards or sign placards telling the mother, “PUSH!”
Quite ridiculous, especially when given the sensible and entirely practical nature of having a quiet birth that is devoid of random chatter, emotional conversations and blathering by medical staff which can then adversely affect the baby (and the mother) later in life.